Friday, January 4, 2013

Kazakhstan – Regulator approves Kazkommertsbank plan to use two subsidiaries to manage problem loans and approves proposal for JP Finance Group to acquire Nurbank; BTA Bank exits 2nd restructuring; businesses in Kazakhstan required to accept debit cards from 1 January; Kaspi Bank declines to continue providing information to Fitch Ratings


On 3 January 2013 the central bank’s financial supervision committee, AFN (АФН РК), published summary information on a number of actions taken on 24 December 2012, including the following:

–  The authority approved requests by Kazkommertsbank («Казкоммерцбанк» АҚ) to establish two subsidiaries to manage problem loans.  The board of directors of Kazkommertsbank had decided on 8 November 2012 to establish two new subsidiaries – distressed asset management companies – to manage distressed loans.  The two companies, to be named “KUSA KKB-1” (for industrial assets) and “KUSA KKB-2” (for commercial and residential real estate), were to be entrusted with assets once regulatory authorization had been obtained.  Kazkommertsbank was ranked #1 in assets among banks in Kazakhstan as of 1 Dec. 2012, with total assets of 2.553 trillion KZT (13.06 bln EUR).  (1 EUR = 195.4912 KZT as of 1 Dec. 2012.)

–   The authority granted consent for a firm identified as “JP Finance Group” to acquire the status of bank holding company for the troubled commercial bank Nurbank ("Нұрбанк" АҚ).  No additional information was published on “JP Finance Group”.  Nurbank, a bank long plagued by management problems – including the kidnapping and murder of two former officers in 2007 – as of 1 Dec. 2012 was ranked 14th among banks in Kazakhstan in assets, with total assets of 252.7 bln KZT (1.293 bln EUR).

In a separate action, on 24 December 2012 the financial supervision committee also issued a written warning to Alliance Bank ("Альянс Банкі" АҚ) for infringement of art. 20, par. 5 of the Law on Banks and Banking Activity in the Republic of Kazakhstan.  The paragraph in question establishes minimum qualifications – minimum periods of previous banking experience – for leading roles in banks, and forbids the exercising of these roles without prior official authorization.  Alliance Bank was ranked #8 in assets as of 1 Dec. 2012, with total assets of 589.9 bln KZT

Sources:
AFN decisions on Kazkommertsbank and Nurbank: Жаңалықтар (2013-01-03)
AFN nforcement actions: Шектеулі ықпал ету шаралары (Dec. 2012)


In earlier news, on 27 December 2012 the commercial bank BTA Bank (“БТА Банк” АҚ) announced that on 24 December it had successfully completed its second restructuring plan, which related to USD 11.1 bln of the bank’s indebtedness.  The bank’s press release summarized the results of the plan as follows:

Key results of the Bank’s Restructuring:

—  the Bank has been recapitalised by approximately U.S.$10 bln. as a result of:
-  the conversion of USD 1,208 mln. of the Bank’s financial indebtedness into common shares and the distribution of shares and GDRs to subordinated debt holders;
-  the cancellation of USD 9,044 mln. of other Claimants’ claims in exchange for a total of USD 1,618 mln. in cash and USD 750 mln. New Notes;
-  the additional capital created through the IFRS treatment of the USD 1,592 mln. loan from Samruk-Kazyna and the increase from 4 per cent. to 6 per cent. of the coupon on the existing Bonds of Samruk-Kazyna JSC.
—  The Bank’s estimated equity and regulatory capital, calculated by the requirements of Basel II, as at 31 December 2012 comprise KZT 219.2 bln. and KZT 195.7 bln., respectively. Owing to this, the Bank as at 31 December 2012 will have a new, sustainable capital structure with Tier 1 ratio of 21.8 per cent. Further, this ratio will be maintained above 10 per cent. Under Basel II based on the Bank’s business plan.
 — The financial indebtedness of the Bank subject to the Restructuring has been reduced from approximately USD 11.1 bln. to approximately USD 3.3 bln. (including approximately USD 600 mln. of deposits remaining in the Bank from Samruk-Kazyna JSC)
 — Samruk-Kazyna has increased its majority shareholding in the Bank to 97.3 per cent., with the Claimants holding in aggregate 2.5 per cent. and minority shareholders who held shares prior to the 2010 Restructuring now holding 0.2 per cent. in aggregate of the Bank’s shares.

Samruk-Kazyna, officially known as Sovereign Wealth Fund “Samruk-Kazyna” JSC («Самұрық-Қазына» Ұлттық әл-ауқат қоры» АҚ), is Kazakhstan’s sovereign wealth fund, which as of 30 September 2012 had total assets of 4.904 trillion KZT (25.5 bln EUR).  As of 1 December 2012, BTA Bank was ranked #3 in assets among banks in Kazakhstan, with total assets of 1.445 trillion KZT (7.396 bln EUR).

Sources:


In other news, as of 1 January 2013 almost all businesses in Kazakhstan are required to accept debit cards, temporary exceptions being made (through the end of 2013) for farmers and fishermen selling their own produce and for merchants operating from kiosks and stalls without access to communication networks.  The change comes about through a law passed in June 2012, Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan on amendments and additions to some legislative acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan on counteracting the legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism.  Businesses that fail to accept debit cards or fail to install the necessary equipment face tax review and administrative sanctions.

Sources:


Finally, on 29 December the rating agency Fitch Ratings updated its ratings for Kaspi Bank ("Kaspi Bank" АҚ), raising the bank’s Long-term Issuer Default Rating from ‘B-‘ to ‘B’ and increasing the bank’s Validity Rating from ‘b-‘ to ‘b’, with an outlook of “stable”.  The improved ratings were due in particular to the high growth rate of the bank’s mass-market retail lending in 2011 and 2012 and to the bank’s strong profit position.  But the agency added that it would no longer be continuing to publish ratings for Kaspi:

Simultaneously, the agency has withdrawn the bank's ratings as Kaspi has chosen to stop participating in the rating process. Therefore, Fitch will no longer have sufficient information to maintain the ratings, and accordingly will no longer provide ratings or analytical coverage.

The bank did not publish any explanation for its decision to stop dealing with Fitch, nor did it bother to publish on its website the higher ratings published by Fitch.  But on 5 December it had published on its website – and distributed widely – a press release announcing the assignment of ratings by Standard & Poor’s ('BB-' long-term, 'B' short-term, and 'kzA-' national scale ratings).  The “Ratings” page on the bank’s website features ratings by Moody’s and S&P, but not by Fitch.  It appears that prior to the 5 December ratings assignment by S&P the bank had not been rated by S&P, which could lead one to suspect that after the publishing of the S&P ratings on 5 December the bank decided to switch its business from Fitch to S&P.

As of 1 December 2012, Kaspi Bank was rated #9 among banks in Kazakhstan by assets, with total assets of 538.9 bln KZT (2.76 bln EUR).  In retained net earnings for the first 11 months of 2012 the bank was #2 among banks in Kazakhstan, with earnings of 15.7 bln KZT (80.2 mln EUR), bested only by Halyk Bank with earnings of 55.5 bln KZT (284.0 mln EUR).

Sources:
Fitch press release: TEXT-Fitch ups Kazakhstan's Kaspi Bank to 'B'; drops ratings (2012-12-28 09:28)
Kaspi Bank website: Ratings: Рейтинги


Mark Pleas
Eastern Europe Banking & Deposits Consultant